This blog is a flipped learning task on "Organizing Research Reading and Writing" . The reflection and application written below will be my understanding of the video lectures on Organizing Research Reading and Writing.
Upon completion of this process, the PhD scholar will be
able to systematically organize and synthesize diverse scholarly
materials and related media by:
1. Formulating and refining focused research questions
(typically 3 to 5) that serve to direct the trajectory of reading and define
the core objective of the research work.
2. Employing categorization and coding systems to
organize collected materials (including articles, books, films, and related
concepts) according to relevant themes, theories (such as sociological,
cultural, or gender studies), and conceptual subdivisions, ensuring the reading
aligns directly with the planned chapters of the dissertation.
3. Applying critical analytical techniques during
reading, specifically by identifying the main concepts, developing personal
observations, inserting comments and cross-connections within digital documents
(using tools like Kindle or word processors), and utilizing questions to
transform preliminary findings into structured chapter content.
4. Integrating historical and contemporary perspectives
on the topic to develop a comprehensive understanding, while continuously
searching for new reading materials using advanced keywords, checking
bibliographies, and leveraging specialized resources like Google Scholar.
5. Maintaining a structured and original approach to
writing by starting the documentation process early, generating drafts, and
ensuring that all findings and ideas are properly cited and reflect a unique
perspective rather than merely reproducing others' ideas.
These are short and important points from the video, now let's discuss it in detail
- Detailed Learning Outcomes for a PhD Scholar
- 1. Conceptualizing the Research Contribution
- 2. Strategic Reading and Research Question Development
- 3. Systematic Organization of Literature and Notes
- 4. Integrating Writing and Critical Analysis
Originality via Application: A PhD is not about isolating yourself or inventing a completely new idea, but about "personalizing" and "applying" existing theoretical frameworks and scholarly findings to your specific topic in an "original manner."
Engagement with the Scholarly Conversation: Recognize that your work is a contribution to a "collective intellectual enterprise" where you must make sense of existing scholarship and clearly delineate your unique input.
The Primacy of Research Questions: Preliminary reading should be used to drive and derive your final 3 to 5 core research questions. These questions serve as the "directional guide" for all subsequent reading and writing.
Clarity Through Effort: Acknowledging that confusion is "normal" at the start of the literature review process, the video stresses that clarity is an outcome of hard work—intense reading, consistent application, and continual synthesis.
Interdisciplinary Insight: Reading related fields (e.g., Sociology, Cultural Studies, History, Film Studies) is essential. These "related areas" significantly influence and deepen the understanding of your core topic, allowing you to view it from a variety of theoretical angles.
Thematic Structuring of Chapters: The literature review should be organized by "themes" or "theories" relevant to your topic (e.g., Social Exclusion, Gender, Modernity, Class) rather than a simple chronological order. Each theme can eventually correspond to an article cluster or a full chapter.
Coding System for Files: Implement a practical system where every article or book excerpt is labeled with a "code" that corresponds to the relevant chapter or theme (e.g., C1, C2.3, TP for Theoretical Perspective). This ensures all material is organized by argument as it is collected.
Annotated Summarizing: For every text, write a brief, summarized note capturing the argument, special examples, and methodology used. This note-taking process prevents plagiarism and helps you internalize the material.
Utilizing Digital Tools: Employ specialized tools like Kindle for reading, highlighting, and commenting to insert your own observations and cross-connections as you read. Use the "Find in Page" option (Ctrl+F) to quickly locate keywords (e.g., bandit, outlaw, social exclusion) within long articles.
The "Answer" as a Section: Use your research questions as a writing prompt. The eventual "answer" to a specific research question will naturally form a paragraph, a sub-section, or an entire chapter in your dissertation.
Developing a Theoretical/Historical Narrative: Use the literature review to develop a "History of the Topic" that traces the past developments, key research, and changes in perception related to your area, positioning your work at the cutting edge of the field.
Citation Hygiene from Day One: Never delay recording complete citation details (page numbers, publication details). Record them immediately to avoid the common, time-consuming mistake of "searching for page numbers" near the submission deadline.
Thesis Structure: A typical structure is suggested:
Introduction
Literature Review (Theories and History of the Topic)
Critical Analysis/Thematic Chapters (Where your original argument is built)
Conclusion (Summarizing findings and providing Directions for Future Research)
No comments:
Post a Comment