A Doll's House Part 2 By Lucas Hnath: An Overview

 

A Doll's House, Part 2 by Lucas Hnath

Source: Excerpts from "A Dolls House Part 2 (Lucas Hnath)"

A Doll's House, Part 2 is a 2017 play written by Lucas Hnath. The play premiered at the South Coast Repertory, in April 2017, before transferring to Broadway at the John Golden Theatre. The play "picks up after Henrik Ibsen's 1879 play A Doll's House concludes" (Source)

Note for Students:

This blog is general overview of the play. If you wish to understand the play and themes of it. We will soon publish a blog that contains thematical study and many questions already discussed in the class. You wont be able to find summary and notes/e-book of the play anywhere on the internet (as of March 2025, can't be sure about future).

Overview:

Lucas Hnath's "A Doll's House, Part 2" picks up fifteen years after Nora Helmer's dramatic exit at the end of Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House." The play centers around Nora's unexpected return to her former home, now a successful and controversial author advocating for the dissolution of marriage. Her primary goal is to finalize her divorce from Torvald, only to discover that he never actually filed the paperwork. The play explores themes of evolving identities, the complexities of marriage and divorce, societal expectations of women, the consequences of Nora's actions, and the possibility of genuine understanding between individuals.

Main Themes and Important Ideas/Facts:

1. Nora's Transformation and Advocacy Against Marriage:

• Changed Identity:
• Nora is no longer the subservient wife who left. She has become an independent, financially successful author with strong convictions. As she tells Anne Marie, "I'm not the same person who left through that door. I'm a very different person."
• 
  
• Author and Advocate:
• Nora's success stems from writing books about women's experiences, particularly the dissatisfactions within marriage. Anne Marie notes, "So you're a popular writer... women's writing is very popular, there's a big interest in- ... what do you write? Books about women."
• 
  
• Critique of Marriage:
• Nora argues that the institution of marriage is inherently flawed and often detrimental to personal growth and happiness. She states, "people change into different people, so how can you say that 'I want to be with this person' when 'this person' is not going to be 'this person' 3 or 5 or 10 years from now, but there you are committed, forever till death stuck, stuck either with a person you don't want to be with or with a person pretending to be a person they no longer are. I mean, I'd even go so far as to say that marriage makes a person change for the worse."
• 
  
• Desire to End Marriage:
• Nora's primary motivation for returning is to obtain a legal divorce, believing it to be a necessary step towards validating her independent life and her public stance against the traditional constraints of marriage. "And so I say, well just end it. End marriage."

2. The Undivorced Reality and its Consequences:

• 
  
• Torvald's Inaction:
• A central conflict arises from the revelation that Torvald never filed for divorce. Anne Marie informs Nora, "...Anne Marie, Torvald never filed the divorce. 15 years ago, he was supposed to, but he didn't and now, I find out that Torvald and I are still husband and wife."
• 
  
• Legal Precariousness:
• This legal reality puts Nora in a dangerous position as her actions and business dealings as an unmarried woman are now potentially illegal. Nora explains, "Because you won't file for the divorce, because you're holding me in this marriage that's not a marriage, you have made me a criminal... I've behaved as an unmarried woman, I have conducted business that married women are not allowed to conduct without the consent of their husbands, signed contracts that are now void, I could be prosecuted and put in prison..."
• 
  
• Blackmail Threat:
• A judge is aware of Nora's controversial writings and her legal status, threatening public exposure unless she retracts her statements. Nora states the judge's demands: "...unless I publicly retract everything I've said in my books, write a letter and have it published in all of the newspapers, apologize for what I wrote apologize for encouraging women to leave bad marriages, and say that what I said was
• wrong and dangerous-"

3. Perspectives on Nora's Departure and its Aftermath:

• 
  
• Anne Marie's Loyalty and Pragmatism:
• Anne Marie, who stayed to raise Nora's children, expresses her initial disbelief and then her concern for Torvald's well-being. She reveals the difficult emotional state Torvald was in after Nora left: "The silence. The not-eating. The very dark thoughts he'd think. The shame-". She is also resentful of the disruption Nora's return causes to her stable life with Torvald, who supports her. "Torvald is all I have in this world, my only family. He takes care of me. He supports me."
• 
  
• Torvald's Wounded Pride and Shifting Understanding:
• Torvald is initially shocked and hurt by Nora's return and the implications of her success and her views on him in her book. He admits, "I come off pretty badly in the book. I come off as a real-". However, reading Nora's book leads to a degree of self-reflection and a painful acknowledgment of his past behavior. "I lived in terror of my husband. He didn't so much look at me, as much as he looked through me. I didn't exist." He later confesses, "I think I miss you, Nora."
• 
  
• Emmy's Pragmatic and Contrasting Views:
• Nora's daughter, Emmy, now a young woman engaged to a banker who works with Torvald, offers a starkly different perspective. While not harboring animosity, she is primarily concerned with the potential scandal that Nora's situation could bring upon her family and jeopardize her own future. "And if you cause a scandal he won't be able to marry me. And there goes my future. Gone." She proposes the drastic solution of faking Nora's death to resolve the legal issues. "You die. ... If you're dead, there is no marriage." Emmy's desire for a traditional marriage ("I want to be held. I want to be somebody's something-") contrasts sharply with Nora's views.

4. The Complexity of Family and Relationships:

• 
  
• Nora's Relationship with her Children:
• Nora acknowledges the distance that has grown between her and her children and initially believes it's better not to reconnect. "they're grown up, they're grown ups, they have their lives, their lives are without me, there's no point-". However, her interaction with Emmy reveals a more complex mix of guilt, curiosity, and a desire to explain her actions, albeit intertwined with her need for help.
• 
  
• Anne Marie's Maternal Role:
• Anne Marie's deep connection with the children and her continued care for Torvald highlight the enduring bonds formed over the years, even in the absence of Nora.
• 
  
• The Lingering Connection Between Nora and Torvald:
• Despite the years of separation and their differing views, there are moments that suggest a lingering, albeit complicated, connection. Torvald's act of finally filing for divorce, even at personal cost, indicates a significant shift, even if motivated by a desire to control the narrative or to finally be free of the past.
• 
  

5. The Difficulty of True Understanding and Change:

• 
  
• Misinterpretations and Assumptions:
• The play highlights how easily individuals misinterpret each other's motives and experiences. Anne Marie misreads Nora's intentions, and Nora makes assumptions about Torvald's desires. Emmy also operates under assumptions about Nora's motivations.
• 
  
• The Struggle for Authentic Selfhood:
• Nora's journey after leaving was about finding her own voice and defining herself outside of societal expectations and marital roles. "It's really hard to hear your own voice, and every lie you tell makes your voice harder to hear, and a lot of what we do is lying. Especially when what we want so badly from other people is for them to love us."
• 
  
• The Question of Forgiveness and Reconciliation: While Torvald eventually takes action to grant Nora the divorce, their final exchange is fraught with anger and unresolved issues. Nora ultimately rejects the divorce on his terms, indicating that true reconciliation or a return to their previous dynamic is impossible. "the divorce, I don't need it."

Quotes Highlighting Key Ideas:

• 
  
• Nora's Transformation:
• "I'm not the same person who left through that door. I'm a very different person" (Nora to Anne Marie).
• 
  
• Nora's View on Marriage:
• "people change into different people, so how can you say that 'I want to be with this person' when 'this person' is not going to be 'this person' 3 or 5 or 10 years from now..." (Nora to Anne Marie).
• 
  
• The Undivorced Reality:
• "Anne Marie, Torvald never filed the divorce. 15 years ago, he was supposed to, but he didn't and now, I find out that Torvald and I are still husband and wife." (Nora to Anne Marie).
• 
  
• Consequences of Undivorced Status:
• "Because you won't file for the divorce, because you're holding me in this marriage that's not a marriage, you have made me a criminal-" (Nora to Torvald).
• 
  
• Torvald's Reflection on Nora's Book:
• "I lived in terror of my husband. He didn't so much look at me, as much as he looked through me. I didn't exist." (Quote from Nora's book read by Torvald).
• 
  
• Emmy's Pragmatism:
• "If you're dead, there is no marriage." (Emmy to Nora).
• 
  
• Nora's Pursuit of Self-Discovery:
• "It's really hard to hear your own voice, and every lie you tell makes your voice harder to hear..." (Nora to Torvald).
• 
  
• Nora Rejecting Torvald's Actions:
• "Thank you, Torvald. I appreciate that you did this ... but ... I don't need this anymore" (Nora to Torvald, regarding the divorce papers).

Conclusion:

"A Doll's House, Part 2" offers a compelling continuation of Nora Helmer's story, delving into the complex aftermath of her radical decision. The play grapples with the evolving understanding of marriage, the challenges women face in achieving true independence, and the enduring impact of past choices on present realities. Through sharp dialogue and contrasting perspectives, Hnath raises profound questions about personal freedom, societal expectations, and the elusive nature of lasting relationships. Nora's ultimate decision to forge her own path, even after Torvald's attempt to rectify the past, underscores her commitment to self-determination and her continued rejection of conventional constraints.